Should I pay for AI visibility tracking software?
- Dane Frederiksen
- 7 hours ago
- 3 min read
No. Christopher Penn says cancel it. AI visibility tracking software cannot tell you what your true AI visibility is because Google personalization changes the answer for every user. If you are paying $5K–$10K a month for one of these tools, save the money — the data is meaningless.
Quick Answer
Anyone selling you AI visibility tracking software is lying about being able to tell you your true visibility.
Google personalizes AI answers based on each user's Gmail, calendar, YouTube history, and search history.
Two people running the same query get different brand recommendations — so the "visibility" number is fiction.
Cancel the subscription. Use a free-form "How did you hear about us?" field on your contact form instead.
Why Christopher Penn says cancel your AI visibility tracking subscription
Christopher Penn, co-founder and chief data scientist at Trust Insights, has built the kind of attribution models that the AI visibility tracking vendors claim to sell. His read is direct: it does not work. The math does not work. The data does not exist.
The reason is personalization. Google said in summer 2024 that "Google does the Googling" — meaning when you query, the AI is also pulling in your Gmail, your calendar, your YouTube subscriptions, your past searches, and your behavior signals to personalize the answer. The more personalization, the more distortion in the output.
"Anyone who is selling you software saying we can tell you what your AI visibility is — zero. They have zero insight. If you're spending money on enterprise AI visibility software, cancel the subscription. Save yourself the five grand to ten grand. It's worthless." — Christopher Penn
The proof point Christopher cites comes from a conference talk by Garrett, who set up synthetic Gmail accounts — five or six fake people, each with different YouTube subscriptions, different Gmail subscriptions, different signal profiles. He ran the same brand-research queries through Google AI for each account. The brands Google recommended varied from account to account based on the personalization. Same query, different answer, every time.
That means no tracking tool, no matter how much it charges, can give you a single accurate number for "your AI visibility." There is no single answer — there are millions of personalized answers. The tool is selling you an average that does not represent any real buyer's experience.
The replacement, in Christopher's framework: add a free-form "How did you hear about us?" text field on your contact form. Analyze the responses monthly with AI. Watch for ChatGPT, Claude, Google, Perplexity, DeepSeek, and Qwen showing up by name. That is real data from real prospects.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why doesn't AI visibility tracking software actually work?
Because AI search results are personalized per user. Google pulls in each user's Gmail, calendar, YouTube history, and search history to generate a personalized answer. Two people get different recommendations for the same query. A tracking tool can only show you an average that no real buyer actually sees.
What should I do instead of paying for AI visibility tracking?
Add a free-form "How did you hear about us?" text field on every contact form and intake point. Analyze the responses monthly using AI. Watch for ChatGPT, Claude, Google AI Mode, Perplexity, DeepSeek, and Qwen showing up by name. That is real measurement from real prospects.
What is the typical cost of AI visibility tracking software?
Enterprise plans run from roughly $5,000 to $10,000 per month, according to Christopher Penn. He recommends cancelling any active subscription because the data the tools produce is not predictive of real buyer experience.
Watch the full interview
Watch Christopher Penn and Dane Frederiksen go deeper on AI visibility, GEO measurement, and why 11% of Trust Insights' revenue now comes from AI search: the full interview with Christopher Penn.
Comments